I think that the question how to hold global corporations
accountable is not a very easy question to answer, it really depends on the
situation and on what kind of corporation. In the case of the clothing companies
that have their clothing produced in the developing world and oftentimes under
awful working conditions in the sweatshops, countries do not hold these
companies accountable either because they cannot because they do not have the
laws in place, or because they simply do not want to because these companies
bring money into the country and create jobs (even though these jobs are under
awful working conditions). In these cases, customers are the ones who could
hold these companies accountable by not buying their products. However,
sometimes we as customers really do not have a choice. Even though we do not
agree with these companies and how they have their clothing produced, we are
still buying their products because a significant number of major clothing
companies have their clothes produced in sweatshops in Third World countries.
However, in the case of VW and its emissions scandal,
countries are willing and are able to hold VW accountable. In many countries,
VW did not abide by the environmental laws in place. Several countries have
started investigations against VW and while the US is the only country so far
that has filed a lawsuit, other countries probably will file lawsuits against
the company, too. This is, of course, a sad example that some countries are
more willing to hold a corporation accountable that breaks environmental laws
than companies that have their products produced under very awful working
conditions.
Therefore, as mentioned above, it really depends on the
situation if and how global corporations can be held accountable for their
actions. In some cases, unfortunately, states rather look the other way than hold
companies accountable. In other cases, states are willing to file large
lawsuits against companies that break their laws.
Christine, it is great that you emphasized the point that not all corporations are created equal nor operate and are motivated by the same things. In addition, the idea of customers as their police, i.e. the ones who hold them ultimately accountable is key. There are many campaigns, branding techniques and advocates that speak out with this goal. Unfortunately, most customers pay little attention as they are not very - if at all- affected by the negative acts themselves.
ReplyDeleteThank you for bring up the example of the Volkswagon emissions scandal. I had not been aware of it and was able to learn from its story.
Hi Christine,
ReplyDeleteGreat post! I completely agree with you, as a consumer you don't want to think the clothes you are buying are made in a sweatshop. Even clothes that are more expensive, how are you to know where exactly it is made and what regulations is it following. How are we to place an international regulation? I wish I could make my own clothes so I know where it came from...however I might not know how ethically made the fabric was. If its not one thing, it could be another.
I like the VW example you provided. It is sad that some states don't care as much about the regulations, but also as a company I hope they can come out of this strong. They are a such a large company I think they can handle this well.